Amy Coney Barrett's Former Classmate Claims She 'Secretly Admits Roe v. Wade Was Right'. Viral rumor claims Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett privately confessed to a former law school classmate that she believes Roe v. Wade was correctly decided, contradicting her public votes. Fact check: False. No credible evidence supports this claim. Barrett has consistently defended her judicial philosophy, and the alleged classmate remains anonymous. The rumor appears to originate from a satirical blog post that was taken out of context.